The force of a car crash can be like that of a bomb exploding. When a few thousand pounds of steel, glass, aluminum and plastic comes to a sudden stop, the kinetic energy must be dissipated, and when it does, the results can be devastating. Twisted metal, toppled walls, and all too frequently, shattered human bodies. The WHO estimates that over 1 million people are killed each year in motor vehicle accidents, including tens of thousands of children. Of these, a tiny proportion are what we might call vehicular homicide, where a driver intentionally hits a victim, or in cases such as drink-driving, operated the vehicle in a dangerous manner. The majority are what we simply call accidents. A momentary lapse in judgment, going too fast, a sudden swerve to avoid a dog or another driver, a failure to stop in slippery conditions. We have accrued a number of safety measures to reduce road fatalities, such as airbags and automatic braking, but there is simply no way to propel two thousand pounds of metal at 70 miles an hour in a completely safe way.
Whenever the IDF kills children, which it does all too frequently, critics would jibe sarcastically about 'the most moral army in the world.' This always seemed strange to me. Did you not think that the most moral army in the world kills kids? As someone who served in the army, or even as someone who has a basic understanding of what military conflict is, it was always obvious to me that the even the most moral army would kill kids. After all, Tesla, Volvo and Toyota also kill a lot of kids. What makes an army moral is how and when it uses deadly force, and what steps it takes to avoid hurting the innocent. Israel does not always get it right, but its methods measure up favorably against other military forces. The militaries of Western powers, such as the US and Great Britain, enjoy greater freedom because of their political power, while non-Western armies don't generally offer more than a performative concern for civilians.
In this war Israel has provided humanitarian accommodations that are unprecedented in the history of military conflict. These include humanitarian ceasefires, planned evacuation of civilians from conflict zones, and the facilitation of food and fuel aid into enemy territory. Israeli families are mourning the loss of 327 sons, brothers and fathers precisely because they didn't do what they are being accused of, which is to indiscriminately carpet bomb from the air. At the same time, over 30,000 Palestinians have been killed, many of them civilians. While the ratio of civilians to combatants compares favorably with similar conflicts, especially given the intermingling of terrorists and terrorist infrastructure with the civilian population, there is no doubt that at least some of these deaths were avoidable. By itself, avoidable deaths don't prove or disprove the justness of the war. After all, if we weren't willing to accept any avoidable deaths then we would ban all forms of motorized transport, not to mention swimming pools, bathtubs, kitchen knives and anything else that could potentially cause fatal damage. But how many is too many? I don't know. I can only tell you that defeating the terrorist organization Hamas and returning the hostages is at least as important to me as driving in a car is to you. So next time you get into a car, think about how many is too many, come up with a number and let me know. I'll calibrate accordingly and get back to you.